| Must Be In | Slenderman, Yami Marik, Fuwatti, Uncle Samsonite, Hymio/Dr. Smiley , Ao Oni (Return), Ronald (Return), Mutant (Return), Dr. Genius, Jake Paul, Tenone/Kyogi/The Rat, Shannon Briggs, Junkbot (OVA Still Canon BTW), Kanye East (Return) |
| Strong Case for Being In | EXE, Starved (+ Furnace), Minos Prime (Lust Sovereign), Smiley Ghost (Return), Viktor Strobovski, Dr. Doom, Aka Manto, Joseph Joestar, XJ (Return), Majora's Moon |
| Could Be Interesting | Jeff the Killer, Does Evil Things Guy, The Thing, MX, Thornwalker |
| 25/50 On this one. | Dr. Fate, Mr. Mix, The Rake, Smile.dog, Granny, Xtreme (Return), Leatherface |
| Strongly Against, But Can see them in. | Tyler1, Mish (Return) |
| Absolutely Not | |
| Decision | |
