| Best Villain Ever | John Kramer/Jigsaw, Hannibal Lecter, Uncle Samsonite, Yami Marik, Dr. Doom, M. Pegasus, Diego Brando, Yoshikage Kira, Funny Valentine, Cell, Enrico Pucci, Goku Black, Palpatine, Merged Zamasu, Future Zamasu, Itachi Uchiha, Pain (Nagato), Obito Uchiha, Madara Uchiha, Valkorion, Darth Vader, Noob Saibot |
| Almost GOAT | Jack Torrance, Jason Voorhees, Freddy Krueger, Drayton Sawyer (The Cook), Michael Myers, Yami Bakura, Sama/Kintoru (Mimic Book 1), Enzukai (Mimic Book 2), Dartz, Ronald, Zorg, DIO, Nightshroud, Supreme King, Diavolo, Kars, Wamuu, Frieza, Deidara, Darth Nihilus, Kisame Hoshigaki, Sasori, Konan, Darth Sion, Darth Malak, Yuuzhan Vong, Licht, Patolli, Darth Revan (somewhat), Thrawn, Shang Tsung, Hans Landa, Quan Chi, Onaga, Kano, Havik, Ermac |
| Love Them | Nubbis Sawyer, Mutant/Killer Croc, Tenome/Kyogi, Bruce the Shark, The Thing, Pennywise, Look-See, Mordeo, Rose the Hat (Dr. Sleep), Mademoiselle (Martyrs), Leatherface, Pinhead, Sartorius, Megan, Mr. Slausen, The Light of Destruction, Majin Buu, Yubel, Esidisi, The Dog (Duck Season) , Zabuza Momochi, Haku, Orochimaru, Pazuzu, Shinnok, Zagred, Kabuto Yakushi, Kimimaro, Hidan, Shao Kahn, Danzo Shimura, Moris Libardirt, Lucifero, Dark Triad (Dante, Vanica, Zenon, Lucius Zogratis) |
| Not Great Not Terrible | Kagemaru, Sound Four, Andre Toulon, Baraka, Seto Kaiba, Vegeta, Theodore Peterson, Beerus, Vados, Whis, Champa, Hit, Gaara, Jiren, Super 17, Gato, Sasuke Uchiha, Liebe, Rat (Cheese Escape), Geras |
| Worse than Average | Billy (Black Christmas), Babidi, Dabura, Sigfried (YuGiOh), Raditz, Nappa, Frost, Garlic Jr., Mizuki, Sindel, Kaguya Ōtsutsuki, Kakuzu, Griefer (or Brad), Ice King (Block Tales) |
| Just Bad | Black Zetsu, Kronika, D'Vorah |
| Unranked | Broly, Paragus, Moro, Granolah, Cooler, Turles, Megicula, Lord Slug, Dr. Wheelo, Meta-Cooler, Android 13, Angol, Hirudegarn, Janemba, Momoshiki Ōtsutsuki, Isshiki Ōtsutsuki, Toneri Ōtsutsuki, Jigen, Code, Kawaki, Boruto (Momoshiki-possessed), Ludwig, Jack, Ramp, Reiko, Cetrion, Dark Raiden, Kollector, Takeda (corrupted), Skarlet, General Shao |
